Current:Home > FinanceThere’s No Power Grid Emergency Requiring a Coal Bailout, Regulators Say-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
There’s No Power Grid Emergency Requiring a Coal Bailout, Regulators Say
View Date:2024-12-24 07:20:03
The top regulators of the nation’s power grid told Congress on Tuesday that they see no immediate national security emergency to justify propping up coal and nuclear power plants with a government order, as the Trump administration is considering.
All five members of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, FERC, weighed in at a hearing of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee on a debate that has been roiling the industry and its regulators for months. It was the first time in many years that the whole commission had appeared before the committee together.
Even though most of them were appointed by President Donald Trump, they seemed ambivalent or even hostile to his repeated attempts, along with Energy Secretary Rick Perry, to require grid operators to buy power from uneconomical coal and nuclear power plants.
Trump political supporters and influential fossil fuel companies, including the coal company Murray Energy and utility FirstEnergy, have pushed for a government-ordered bailout, while a diverse mix of environmental advocates, major grid operators and some public utility companies and natural gas suppliers have argued strongly against it.
The administration wants to keep coal and nuclear generators from being driven out of business by cheaper natural gas or carbon-free wind and solar. A few months ago, FERC rebuffed Perry’s attempt to subsidize plant operators who keep 90 days of fuel on hand. Now, the White House has told Perry to use his own emergency powers under two laws to bail the industry out on grounds that plant closures are presenting a national security emergency.
But the idea that the grid is currently so frail as to present an urgent military crisis has received little support, and next to none at the commission.
FERC’s chairman, Kevin McIntyre, reading a formal statement aloud, spoke of the deliberative approach the commission has adopted: opening a docket to solicit the views of all parties, especially the grid operators with the fingertip control of electricity supply. To Trump and his allies, this is bureaucratese for kicking the can down the road and risks providing too little assistance too late.
Vigilance, but No Rush to Intervene
Commissioner Neil Chatterjee, a Kentucky native and former energy advisor to pro-coal Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), was the most receptive to some kind of action, if not on an emergency basis.
“In my view, ‘no action’ is like driving your car without a seat belt,” he said.
Other commissioners echoed Chatterjee’s call for “vigilance.” But while they said it was important to keep the grid resilient during storms, heat waves, cold snaps or market upheavals, they looked askance at emergency federal intervention that would favor one fuel or another.
That, said Commissioner Robert Powelson, a former member of Pennsylvania’s Public Utility Commission and past president of the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners, would be “a real step back” from the benefits that have accrued to competing fuel suppliers and to consumers alike.
It would also retreat from the climate and other environmental benefits from wind and solar, as well as from storage technologies and smart metering that are helping to clean up the grid.
Commissioners Richard Glick, a former official with energy company Iberdrola, and Cheryl LaFleur, a former executive at National Grid USA who was appointed to FERC by President Barack Obama in 2010, were most hostile to the Trump plan.
“We cannot try to stop the natural evolution of this industry by claiming that there is a national security emergency unless there is evidence that suggests that an emergency actually exists,” Glick said.
GOP Senator also Skeptical of Emergency Claim
After more than an hour of testimony, Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.) asked the question directly:
“Do any of you believe that in the wholesale power markets we are facing an actual national security emergency at the moment?”
“I do not,” said LaFleur, the most outspoken of the commission’s opponents of intervention.
“Would anyone answer that with a yes?” Heinrich inquired.
Nobody did.
Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, the committee’s chairwoman, also said she was skeptical.
“As with many controversies, with so much at stake in such a heavily regulated industry such as energy, the various interests are locked in,” she noted. “This is battle, this is mortal conflict for some.”
Murkowski is closely aligned with the oil and gas industry. Its lobbying group, the American Petroleum Institute, has joined renewable energy advocates to strongly oppose the administration’s efforts on behalf of coal and nuclear.
‘FERC Does Not Pick Winners and Losers’
The committee’s ranking Democrat, Maria Cantwell of Washington, said she found the idea of intervening in markets “mind-boggling.”
The commissioners, in more measured words, seemed to agree with her.
“FERC does not pick winners and losers in the market,” Powelson said. “Instead we create an environment where the market can pick the winners and losers.” He called it a “moral hazard” to do otherwise.
“We need to be wary of people using the situation or a potential situation as a way to achieve market changes that they haven’t been able to achieve otherwise,” Glick said.
veryGood! (622)
Related
- Trump announces Tom Homan, former director of immigration enforcement, will serve as ‘border czar’
- Israel-Hamas truce deal for hostage release hits last-minute snag, now expected to start Friday
- Zoë Kravitz Shares Glimpse of Her Gorgeous Engagement Ring During Dinner Date With Fiancé Channing Tatum
- NY Governor: No sign of terrorism in US-Canada border blast that killed two on Rainbow Bridge
- Monument erected in Tulsa for victims of 1921 Race Massacre
- 10 days after India tunnel collapse, medical camera offers glimpse of 41 men trapped inside awaiting rescue
- 8 Family Members Killed in 4 Locations: The Haunting Story Behind The Pike County Murders
- Mexico arrests alleged security chief for the ‘Chapitos’ wing of the Sinaloa drug cartel
- Federal judge orders Oakland airport to stop using ‘San Francisco’ in name amid lawsuit
- ‘You lose a child, but you’re so thankful': Organ donation bonds families in tragedy, hope
Ranking
- Roy Haynes, Grammy-winning jazz drummer, dies at 99: Reports
- Maui residents wonder if their burned town can be made safe. The answer? No one knows
- Maui residents wonder if their burned town can be made safe. The answer? No one knows
- Washoe County school superintendent’s resignation prompts search for 5th new boss in 10 years
- Mike Tyson is expected to honor late daughter during Jake Paul fight. Here's how.
- 28 Black Friday 2023 Home Deals That Are Too Good to Pass Up, From Dyson to Pottery Barn
- What Happened to the Great Lakes Offshore Wind Boom?
- Brazilian police bust international drug mule ring in Sao Paulo
Recommendation
-
AIT Community Introduce
-
Win at sports and life: 5 tips from an NFL Hall of Famer for parents, young athletes
-
The US and the Philippines conduct joint air, sea patrols in South China Sea not far from Taiwan
-
A Thanksgiving guest's guide to Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce
-
Footage shows Oklahoma officer throwing 70-year-old to the ground after traffic ticket
-
13 Secrets About Mrs. Doubtfire Are on the Way, Dear
-
Sister Wives' Christine and Janelle Brown Reveal When They Knew Their Marriages to Kody Were Over
-
What is a hip-drop tackle? And why some from the NFL want it banned. Graphics explain